home
contact us
site map
disclaimer
privacy policy


Class Actions
  Hamilton Street Railway/OMERS Pension Class Proceeding
 
Home
 
Documents

Pension Surplus

Bankruptcy and Insolvency

Other Cases





  Client Links


 Publications



 Our Firm


Hamilton Street Railway/OMERS Pension Class Proceeding

To contact us please call 1 888 723 4304 or send us an e-mail.


Updated: November 22, 2007

The application was scheduled for hearing on common issues #1 - 5 in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice on November 13-16, 2007. The parties attended a pre-trial conference on November 9, 2007 with Justice Campbell, and agreed to adjourn the hearing pending the continuation of good faith settlement discussions between the parties. The parties have decided to appoint a mutually agreeable mediator and to exchange all information necessary to assist in settling the application. The case remains under the supervision of Justice Campbell, or such other judge of the Commercial List.

On June 29, 2006 the Ontario Superior Court of Justice certified a class proceeding against The Corporation of the City of Hamilton and Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement Board (the Respondents) on behalf of all persons, wherever resident, who on or between July 1, 1965, and June 29, 2006 accrued a benefit in respect of The Hamilton Street Railway Pension Plan (1994) and its predecessor pension plans (the "HSR Plan") (collectively, the "Plan Members"), and the annuitants, spouses, estates and beneficiaries of such Plan Members (the "Class Members").

To see a copy of the Certification Order, please click on the "Documents" tab on the left panel of this screen.

Summary of the Claim

Budh Singh Dhillon and Charan Singh Mangat have been appointed as the Representative Applicants on behalf of the Class in connection with a court application against the Respondents. The application concerns the alleged failure of the City to enrol Class members in the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System (the "OMERS Plan") as it may have been required to do under applicable by-laws, statutes, pension plan rules and other applicable laws. The Representative Applicants are seeking various forms of declaratory relief, including an order that Class Members are required to be enrolled in the OMERS Plan. The Representative Applicants are also seeking damages from the City (and not from OMERS), payable to Class members for any pension losses. These matters have not yet been determined by a court.

There is more important information about the application which can be read in the Notice of Certification available here.

Class Members and Right to Opt Out

Any affected person who wishes to opt out of the class action as certified must do so by sending a written and signed Notice of Intention to Opt-Out to Koskie Minsky LLP on or before September 1, 2006 to the following address:
    KOSKIE MINSKY LLP
    Barristers and Solicitors
    Suite 900, 20 Queen Street West
    Toronto, ON M5H 3R3

    Attention: Hamilton Street Railway/OMERS Pension Class Proceedings
indicating that he or she is opting out of the class action as certified. No person may opt out a minor or a mentally incapable person without permission of the Court after notice to the Children's Lawyer and/or the Public Trustee, as appropriate.

Affected persons who opt out will not be bound by any decision of the Court in the action and may not benefit from any such decision or a settlement.

Any affected person who does not opt out prior to the above date will be a class member and will be bound by the Court's judgment, whether favourable or not.

Please note that there are no legal costs to you if you are a Class Member. Class members will have an opportunity to opt-out of the class if they so desire, but will be required to retain their own counsel or act on their own behalf to pursue the claim.

If you do not wish to be part of the class, you may still be entitled to participate in the proceeding. Such participation is subject to the Court's approval. You may wish to obtain independent legal advice with respect to this matter.

If you have any questions regarding this action please call our hotline number at 1-888-723-4304 where you can leave us a confidential voice message. You can also email us at hamiltonpension@kmlaw.ca or fax us at 416 204-2897 or contact us by mail at Hamilton Street Railway/OMERS Pension Class Proceedings c/o Koskie Minsky LLP, 20 Queen Street West, Suite 900, Toronto, Ontario M5H 3R3.

To view more information about how class actions work, please click here.

IMPORTANT NOTE:

This website has been developed to provide general information to Class Members.

The site is not designed to answer questions about your individual situation or entitlement. Do not rely upon the information provided on this web site as legal advice in respect of your individual situation nor use it as a substitute for individual legal advice.

This website will be updated from time to time to provide Class Members with information as it becomes available.



Copyright © Koskie Minsky LLP, 2008